Would not overtrust it, but No reason to ignore it either. The use case is clear, and it helps if the setup is already disciplined. A cautious first pass gives a cleaner opinion.

I liked it more as a side tool for oscillator setups than as something to follow blindly. Timing feels less random, and the final decision still feels like it belongs to the trader. Profit alone is not enough if average R is weak.

for oscillator setups, this feels more useful as a filter than a full system. The journal should cover 76 setups and the trade context.